Not a Fan of the Stadium Bill

Dear Friends,
This past week the Minnesota Legislature adjourned. Before leaving St. Paul, we voted on the much anticipated Viking stadium bill.

I have rarely missed a game in 50 years. In short, I’m a big Vikings fan.

This was not about being a fan. It was about how much was being spent and who was going to pay for it. It was a $1 billion stadium and it deserved close scrutiny from your legislator.

Ask yourself these questions:

  • Is it really government’s role to finance private business?
  • Should government provide subsidies to private business (which we call corporate welfare)?
  • After the tough economic decisions that were made to bring Minnesota back to financial stability, is it really prudent to spend another $1/2 billion dollars on a private business that is currently profitable?
  • When the state owes our schools $2 billion, is it right to spend $1/2 billion on private business?

I think the answer to each of these is “no”.

Number of Jobs – Grossly Overstated
The argument that a stadium will spur economic development is empty and false. Numerous economists have published reports that found stadiums do not provide economic opportunity for the host city or state. While the construction jobs that will result are a positive thing, the number of jobs has been overstated substantially. The number of jobs reported by media sources has been between 7,000-10,000 jobs. However, these are not full time jobs. According to the general contractor, Mortenson Construction, the number of project hours is estimated to be 4 million over the three year construction time period. This is the equivalent of 2,000 full time jobs or 667 full time jobs in each of the three year period of construction. While important, the number of jobs is much less than what has been reported.

Taxpayers in Jeopardy
The finance mechanism to pay for the stadium, electronic pull tabs, is not feasible, and will not produce the tax revenues being claimed. In Iowa, the same electronic pull tabs were tried and tax collection estimates failed to materialize-they didn’t even come close. If we are going to meet the revenue projections, people who participate in charitable gambling will need to triple the expenditures they make. That is not believable.

If this plan defaults, and history with electronic pull tabs suggests it will, the backup funding plan is Minnesota’s General Fund. That means you, the taxpayer, will pick up the debt. So instead of providing tax relief – or for those who want to increase spending on schools or health or human services – your tax dollars will instead be used for stadium payments.

Perhaps Financing a New Saints Baseball Stadium?
Also, the stadium bill included $2.7 million in annual payments to the City of St. Paul by Minnesota taxpayers. These payments will last 20 years and are expected to be used to either pay down Xcel Energy Center bonds or to build a new St. Paul Saints baseball stadium. Rumor has it these payments were made to pay for the votes of St. Paul lawmakers. Five St. Paul representatives voted for the bill, while only two Minneapolis reps voted for it, even though their city received the $1 billion stadium.

Vikings could pay as little as 1% of the total cost!
Another issue for me was the size of the contribution by the Vikings, widely and inaccurately, reported as $477 million.

$200 Million-
What is not reported is that the Vikings will receive up to $200 million in naming rights on this “people’s stadium.”
$200 Million-
They also have rights to sell personal seat licenses from which they could receive $100-$200 million.
$200 Million-
In addition, the Vikings will receive a loan/gift from the National Football League for upwards of $200 million.
Exemption-More benefits include a clause in the bill which allows the Vikings to be exempt from state laws requiring public disclosure for taxpayer funded benefits. The public will never know how much in public benefits these owners receive.

All of these, in sum, mean that the Vikings owners, clearly within the top 1% of the income bracket in our country, could be responsible for as little as 1% of the stadium cost. Ironic isn’t it, given all the outrage over the last year from Occupy Minnesota, who were strangely silent over the past few weeks.

I voted “No”.
Because of these facts and others, I could not, in good conscience, vote for the stadium bill. The deal with Vikings is a poor one for Minnesota taxpayers.

Thank you to all who contacted my office regarding this issue. I appreciate hearing from you and I hope you will continue to do so.

Best Regards,
Roger Crawford

Posted in News |

Stadium Update

Dear Friends,
For those following the debate on state funding for the Vikings stadium, you are already aware that the bill passed the House and Senate. It is now in the Conference Committee to resolve the differences, which are substantial. For those that contacted me along the way, thank you for weighing in! I appreciated reading and listening to all your comments.

I have been a fan of the Vikings since they played their first game at the old Met. They beat the Bears 37-13, I believe, when Fran Tarkenton came in relief of George Shaw and threw four TD passes. I’ve watched all four Super Bowls, seen the Hail Mary catch with Rashad, witnessed two NFC championship losses and hundreds of other games. However, this is not about being a fan. It is about how much to pay, who pays and are the numbers presented trustworthy. After all, this is a $1.2 billion proposal and should get close scrutiny from your legislator.

In a nutshell, the state funding numbers for the new untested electronic pull tabs don’t work and the state is on the hook for the entire $600+ million of general fund public financing.

There are conditions that could get my support for a new stadium. That stance, taken after much input from my local people, was conditional to no general fund money at risk and having user fees to pay for the stadium. These amendments and efforts did not succeed so I voted no on the final proposal.

In the St. Paul newspaper this week, there was a story about the Vadnais Sports Arena audit. It stated that the hoped-for revenue is falling short. It is delinquent in remitting a year’s worth of sales taxes to the state amongst many other financial issues. That will leave the local property taxpayers to foot the bill.

Passion for the Minnesota Vikings doesn’t mean that we put Minnesota judgment on hold. My job is to make sure that the taxpayers are properly protected and that I have confidence in the funding proposals. I don’t want the State of MN to be in a situation like the story above.

Alternatives were offered that took a sounder and more market based approach. However, the Vikings reject user fees and the Governor rejects infrastructure bonding.

The mechanism that is left is a poorly constructed financing proposal. It puts our taxpayers on the hook to bail out the stadium in the future with dollars that could go to other state needs.

I voted against the current stadium bill. I hope the conference committee report comes back with better funding so I can support the bill on final passage. There is time to fix it. I hope the conference committee accomplishes that. My support can be gained with the proper funding proposal.

Again, thanks to all for your contributions to this process.
Roger

State Rep. Roger Crawford
District 08B
Pine, Kanabec, & Isanti counties
421 State Office Building
100 Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
St. Paul, MN 55155
651-296-0518

Posted in House Updates, News |

Tax Relief and Job Creation Act: May 1, 2012

Dear Friends,

Tax Relief and Job Creation Act Passed  May 1, 2012
The Tax Relief and Job Creation Act passed on the House floor today embodies a much needed market-based approach to tax policies. It also makes most of them permanent so businesses have some certainty in their future.

Considering the fact that Minnesota is near the bottom on the Tax Climate Index and our neighboring states are near the top, this bill is vital. Making Minnesota a more economically competitive and attractive place for job creation is a policy that deserves the Governor’s signature. This bill keeps money in the pockets of small business owners who know how to create jobs. It encourages businesses to stay here, expand here, move their operations here and create more jobs for our Minnesotans.

The Bill:

  • Permanently freezes the automatic inflator on the statewide levy for commercial/industrial properties. This means businesses will keep more of their money to invest in employees and growth, not job-killing-suck-you-dry taxes.
  • Emphasizes policies to encourage high-growth industries to encourage Minnesota businesses to be a magnet for the medical device and bio-technology industry.
  • Provides incentives to create a well-trained work force in Greater Minnesota not just the twin cities area.
  • Provides incentives to help our veteran men and women who did their job and fought for our country get jobs when they come back home.
  • Reforms targeted programs to make sure they are more helpful to our Minnesota-based businesses, especially in rural Minnesota.

Minnesota’s business property tax rate ranks among the highest in the United States. We need to make our state competitive to foster business development, expansion and job growth. Eliminating the property tax will allow businesses to put their money into growth and employees, not paying more taxes. From our local businesses and local government leaders, the statewide general property tax is one of the greatest obstacles to attracting businesses to our area. What does the bill do?

  • Freezes the current rate for statewide tax on business property permanently.
  • Permanently provides an up-front sales tax exemption on capital equipment purchases for all small businesses.
  • Permanently eliminates the accelerated sales tax remittance for 11 months of the year, allowing small businesses to keep more of their money to help with monthly cash flow.
  • Provides a property tax credit toward producers still under testing requirements for bovine tuberculosis.
  • Modifies the sales tax exemption for data centers to make it easier for small businesses to take advantage of this job creation opportunity.
  • Provides property tax relief to homeowners whose property taxes increased by more than 12%: 90% payable this year and 75% after that. There are no income restrictions but the increase must be at least $100 in one year.

In order for Minnesota to increase jobs, we need Minnesota to become a magnet for the high tech industry. We do that by investing in programs that will encourage the growth of the medical device and bio tech industries in our state which creates good paying jobs for our citizens.

Angel Investor Credit

  • Permanently increases Angel Investment Credit by $5 million for the duration of the program and enhances effort to push m ore investment to Greater Minnesota.
  • Prohibits businesses who receive the credit from selling or making a public offer within 6 months
  • Allows public employees or contracted personel contract information to be shared with the public

Research and Development

  • Increases the Research and Development tax credit by 24% for Minnesota companies to help make Minnesota a more attractive place to do business and enables companies to create high-paying jobs throughout the state.

Minnesota Investment Fund
Minnesota is #42 from the bottom on the Entrepreneur Index.

  • Increased funding to the Minnesota Investment Fund, which helps spur economic growth and job creation across Minnesota, by $2 million for FY13.

Greater Minnesota is in need of qualified and trained workers. Our jobs bill creates an internship grant program designed to attract and keep talent in the rural areas of our state. We also create a permanent tax credit to encourage employers to hire the men and women who have served our country.

  • Create Internship Grant Program that is aimed at attracting and keeping talent in Greater Minnesota. Administered through the Office of Higher Education, this program provides 40% grant up to $1250 per intern to employers (maximum of 5 interns per employers)
  • Veterans jobs tax credit aimed at making sure the men and women who serve our country are employed when they return.

Financially, these are modest changes, but have a very large return. In these times, employers have many choices and many places that are eager to have their jobs. Unless we are competitive with our surrounding states and world, our children will graduate and leave for jobs elsewhere. This bill lets them know we notice, we care and are taking the actions we can to help!

Thank you to all for your help in voicing your concerns about small businesses surviving and helped to put this package of tax relief and job promoting policies together.

As always, I welcome your calls at 651-296-0518 or your emails @rep.roger.crawford@house.mn.

Sincerely,
Roger Crawford
421 State Office Building
100 Rev Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
St. Paul, MN 55155
651-296-0518
rep.roger.crawford@house.mn

 

Posted in House Updates, News |

Historic School Land Trust Bill Passed & Signed

Dear Friends,

The historic School Land Trust Bill was passed overwhelmingly by both the House and Senate and signed into law by the Governor this weekend. Maybe you did not notice since all the coverage was about a stadium. However, we do much good work here that does not make such coverage but is very valuable to the citizens.

Like other states, when Minnesota was granted statehood, one section of land in each township was required to be set aside for the benefit of the school students. Minnesota chose to set aside two sections of land in each township. Upon acceptance of this land grant, a permanent school trust fund was created. These lands were to be managed in such a way that they would generate financial revenue to a trust fund. The fund principle generates interest and dividends which are distributed each year to every school district in the State. Currently, there are more than 2.5 million acres of school land trust property that is supposed to be managed to benefit funding education in the state. These lands currently fall under the management of the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (DNR).

The goal of this bill is to shift sole management of the School Trust Lands away from the DNR, which has an inherent conflict of interest between environmental decisions or revenue production for the school students. This bill creates two sources for oversight of the land while still leaving the day-to-day (boots on the ground) efforts in the hands of the DNR.

1. Director of School Trust Lands

  • Appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate
  • Housed within the Department of Administration
  • Funded for a staff of up to 5 people
  • Will assume responsibilities currently handled by Department of Natural Resources staff (does not create “more government†)
  • Would work in collaboration with the DNR commissioner on the management and administration of school trust lands with the sole purpose of maximizing revenues for the purpose of education

2. Legislative Permanent School Fund Commission

  • Made up of twelve Legislative members: six from the Senate and six from the House, representing both the Majority and Minority party equally
  • Will provide advice to the director regarding management of the trust lands
  • Will review reports submitted by the Director to assure revenues are being maximized

Other Facts:

Income from the school trust lands have been averaging between $22 million and $27 million annually over the past five years.

Income from forestry on the lands during the past two years dropped 22 percent, and money transferred to the fund had dropped 84 percent.

Minnesota is in the bottom third of states for Land Trust revenue.

In 16 years after making a similar management change, the state of Utah’s trust fund money grew from $18 million to $1.3 billion.

While maximizing revenue, all laws governing caring for the environment will continue to be in place

This is a common sense effort toward positive reform for the express purpose of the original intent of granting this land to Minnesota in statehood and most importantly for its purpose of to be managed to the benefit of our kids. As the legislative stewards for this fund, it is our obligation to make sure the revenue for those funds are being maximized and used for its original intent.

You may hear about partisanship, but I think the passing of the School Land Trust bill will demonstrate some thoughtful efforts across party lines to the benefit of our schools. This is the culmination of a multi-year effort led by many legislators both democrats and republicans.

As always, I welcome your calls at 651-296-0518 or your emails @rep.roger.crawford@house.mn.

Sincerely,

Roger Crawford
421 State Office Building
100 Rev Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
St. Paul, MN 55155
651-296-0518
rep.roger.crawford@house.mn

Posted in House Updates, News |

Legislative Update

Hello Neighbors,
While the Legislature is in recess this week, I would like to take this time to look back on the accomplishments from the 2012 Legislative session. As you know, our legislative agenda for this session has been reform efforts focused on promoting fiscal responsibility, job growth, quality education and a smarter, quicker and more transparent government. Below is a list detailing the top 10 measures that were passed in the House over the last 12 weeks.

TOP 10 HIGHLIGHTS FROM THE 2012 LEGISLATIVE SESSION

1. Tax Relief
Voted to end the statewide tax on business property, improving our state’s tax climate in an area where Minnesota is especially uncompetitive.

2. Cut the Red Tape
Voted to reduce duplicative government bureaucracy and provide more certainty in the permit process for job creators.

3. K12 Shift
Voted to repay back the additional 10% shift to balance the budget in 2011 and make the first downpayment on the $2 billion debt left behind by the DFL.

4. LIFO
Voted to end illogical and outdated Last In, First Out law that puts a poor teacher’s right to a job ahead of a child’s right to a good teacher.

5. Spending Transparency
Voted to require easy-to-understand budget transparency by cities in order to educate and engage taxpayers in local government spending decisions.

6. Voter ID
Voted to support the Voter ID constitutional amendment, which will require voters to show a Photo ID when they vote, preserving and enhancing election integrity.

7. Veterans
Voted to support a permanent tax credit for employers who hire veterans who are disabled, unemployed or receive food stamps; and an expansion of the GI bill.

8. Welfare Reform
Voted to eliminate welfare fraud and ensure the people who need assistance are receiving it and taxpayer dollars for public assistance are being used as intended – for the needy, not the greedy.

9. Permanent Schools Trust Fund
Reforms how the state will manage permanent school trust lands to maximize economic returns for our schools.

10. Defeated Job Killing Tax Increases…Again
Defeated every attempt to raise job-killing tax increases. News of positive economic forecasts resulting in a $1.2 billion surplus didn’t stop Governor Dayton and the DFL from pushing job-killing tax increases to pay for more government spending.

As always, I welcome your calls at 651-296-0518 or your emails @ rep.roger.crawford@house.mn.

Sincerely,

Roger Crawford
421 State Office Building
100 Rev Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
St. Paul, MN 55155
651-296-0518
rep.roger.crawford@house.mn

Posted in House Updates | Tagged , , , , , , , ,

Pro-Job Bills

Dear Friends,
A reminder that Rep. Kurt Bills is running for the U.S. Senate endorsement and will be speaking at a Simply Right event at Tobies, Thursday, Apr. 12 at 6 p.m. More Info >

Here is an update on the various pro-job bills we are working on in the House.  In addition, the Legislature passed a photo ID bill.  Minnesotans will be asked the following question on their November ballot: “Shall the Minnesota Constitution be amended to require all voters to present valid photo identification to vote and to require the state to provide free identification to eligible voters, effective July 1, 2013?”  Since, 1858, our Minnesota Constitution has been amended 120 times, most recently in 2008.

Pro-Job Bills

Reduce and Eliminate the Statewide Business Property Tax

  • Phase out statewide tax on business property over a 12 year span beginning in 2014.
    • Exempts 70% of the first $150,000 of value for all business property in tax year 2013, especially benefiting rural small businesses.
  • Freezes statewide tax on business properties for one year.

Private Sector Innovation

  • Angel Investor: Permanently increase the limit from $12 million to $17 million. Enhanced effort to push more investment in Greater Minnesota.
  • R&D: Increase the Research and Development tax credit by $25 million to encourage entrepreneurship and job growth.
  • Support Emerging Industries: Help small start up Minnesota companies access immediate capital to expand.

Job Training and Placement

  • Create Internship Grant Program aimed at attracting and keeping talent in Greater Minnesota. Provides a 40% grant up to $1250 per intern.
  • Provide a tax credit for employers who hire veterans who are disabled, unemployed or receive food stamps. This tax credit is up to $14,400 per veteran.

Lawsuit Abuse

  • Improves fairness in litigation and drastically reduces the rate of excessive claims that eat up court time and prevent businesses from investing in jobs and innovation.
  • Minnesota’s lawsuit environment is one of the worst in the nation, making it easy to game the system with frivolous and abusive lawsuits. Our businesses operate in a climate permeated by the fear of these frivolous lawsuits and windfall verdicts that can lead to layoffs, decreased production or shutdowns.
  • These reforms are supported by 45 regional Chambers of Commerce and Trade Associations that together represent more than 60,000 employers in Minnesota.

Red Tape

  • Speed Up Process
    • Provide more options and different ways for job creators to efficiently and effectively move through the permitting process.
    • Allow job creators to hire outside experts to help them draft permits.
    • Remove duplicate reviews
  • Navigate the Process
    • Hold DEED Commissioner accountable for administration and implementation of environmental permits.
    • Create a jobs advocate to support new and developing businesses.
  • Permissive Permitting
    • Issues minor permits in 60 days if MPCA/DNR fail to approve or deny minor permits or minor amendments in that time frame.
  • Start Construction Faster
    • Allow construction projects to start prior to receiving permits if it doesn’t violate federal law.
  • Reform Rulemaking
    • Allows Legislature to object and amend rulemaking; requires Sunset Commission to determine which ones to repeal, amend or leave alone.
    • Levels the playing field for businesses and citizens directly impacted by state agency permitting and rulemaking by make the Office of Administrative Hearings in contested cases the final say-not the state agency.

As always, your comments on these other issues are welcome.

Sincerely,
Roger Crawford
421 State Office Building
100 Rev Dr Martin Luther King Jr Blvd
St. Paul, MN 55155
651-296-0518
rep.roger.crawford@house.mn

Posted in Business Climate, House Updates, News | Tagged , , , , , , ,

Kurt Bills for Senate at Tobies Thursday

Meet Rep. Kurt Bills for Senate
@ Tobies Thursday, April 12

Rep. Kurt Bills will be speaking at a Simply Right event in the Little Kettle Room of Tobies in Hinckley on Thursday, April 12 at 6:00 p.m. I have the pleasure of working with him in the legislature and will be honored to introduce him at this event.

Rep. Bills is an economics teacher from Rosemount running for the United States Senate. He first won election to the Minnesota House in 2010 and has been a truly solid advocate for limited government in the Legislature. Check out the campaign’s Website at www.KurtBills.com.

Direct any questions about the event to (320)279-2684.

Hope to see you on Thursday!
Roger

 

Posted in News |

Tax Relief & Jobs Creation | Info on Education

Dear Friends,

Tax Relief and Jobs Creation Act:

A bill designed to reduce taxes and create jobs passed the Minnesota House of Representatives last week. The package of wide-ranging initiatives is called the Tax Relief and Jobs Creation Act (H.F. 2337). The Tax Relief and Job Creation Act will make Minnesota a more economically competitive and attractive place for job creation.

This bill is focused on Minnesota business and employment growth, which will stimulate long-term economic activity. It encourages businesses to stay here, expand here, move their operations here and create more jobs. This act declares to job creators around the country that Minnesota is open for business.

There are several very important measures in the act. They include:

  • A statewide business property-tax reduction to begin a 12-year phase-out process.
  • A $25 million increase in research-and-development credits for Minnesota companies.
  • A permanent $5 million increase in the Angel Investment Tax Credit.
  • Allowing small businesses to take up-front capital equipment exemptions.
  • A tax credit for businesses that hire veterans.

This bill has been sent to the Senate for approval and then will go to the governor for his signature. I urge both bodies to support these measures so we can offer Minnesotans some relief and get people back to work as soon as possible.

Education:

A few interesting bits of information on Education-

Just in case you missed it, below is an article I wrote and was published in the Kanabec County Times on March 7, 2012-

Crawford explains teacher seniority bill
“A number of people have asked me a question or two about a recent vote in the Minnesota House of Representatives.

The bill in question would change state law which currently mandates that those teachers who were the last ones hired be the first ones laid off (defined as LIFO) in the unfortunate situation where school districts have to lay off teachers.

HF1870 would allow for other factors, such as teacher performance and teacher effectiveness to be used, in addition to seniority.

Let me explain why I support this measure and what the benefits might be…” Read More >

——
Did you ever wonder why tuition is so high at the U?
Check these salaries out. http://extra.twincities.com/car/salaries/
——

As always, I welcome your calls at 651-296-0518 or your emails @ rep.roger.crawford@house.mn.

Roger

Posted in House Updates, News |

Photo ID Constitutional Amendment Bill Passes the House

St. Paul – The Minnesota House of Representatives today passed the photo ID constitutional amendment bill on a vote of 72-62. The bill, House File 2738, allows for a public vote in the November election on a photo ID voting requirement.

Under the bill, a ballot question would ask if voters would like to add an amendment to the Minnesota Constitution that would require that, on Election Day, all voters present valid photo identification prior to casting a ballot. A majority vote of the people would amend the constitution, and the Legislature would implement the new photo ID requirement in 2013. This amendment would also require state identification be made available at no charge to those who do not already have an ID.

The amendment preserves the ability of all eligible Minnesotans, including military members, college students, and the elderly, to continue voting with ease. It also keeps in place same day voter registration and absentee voting. Representative Mary Kiffmeyer (R-Big Lake), the chief author of the bill, testified on the House floor on behalf of her bill.

“I think it is fitting that this measure be given approval by our voting public,” said Representative Kiffmeyer. “Polls are showing overwhelming public support for a photo ID voting requirement; and this will finally put that decision where it belongs, in the hands of the Minnesota voters. This measure will add some much needed integrity to our voter registration system.”

Speaker of the House Kurt Zellers (R-Maple Grove) added “Minnesotans deserve to know their vote counts. Photo ID is a simple, common sense measure that protects the integrity of our elections and instills greater confidence in the process.”

House File 2738 must be approved by the Minnesota Senate before it will appear on the ballot this November. The amendment does not include any mandates for spending or technology requirements. Enacting legislation would be decided by the Legislature only after the amendment is approved during the 2012 November election.

###

Roger Crawford represents District 8B in the Minnesota House of Representatives, which includes the cities of Pine City and Mora. Crawford encourages constituents to contact him with questions or opinions on any state legislative issue. He may be reached at rep.roger.crawford@house.mn or 651.296.0518. Mail should be sent to Rep. Roger Crawford, 421 State Office Building, 100 Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd., St. Paul, MN 55155.

Posted in House Updates, News |

Crawford Endorsed at District Convention

Press Release

March 19, 2012
Mora, MN

Rep. Roger Crawford

Rep. Roger Crawford

Rep. Roger Crawford (R-Mora) was unanimously endorsed in his race for reelection Friday night by District 11B Republicans.  Over 100 delegates gathered to choose Crawford who is serving his first term in the Minnesota House of Representatives. “It is an honor to have your endorsement and I pledge to work hard to win this seat. If re-elected, I will continue my work in the Minnesota House to keep us on the path to a healthy jobs climate, greater spending control, and tax reform.”  Crawford serves on the Commerce, Tax, Property Tax, and Education Reform committees.

Crawford is a former mayor of Mora and Kanabec County Commissioner. He served in the U.S. Navy and is a small business owner in Mora. He is married to his wife of 39 years Barbara. They have four grown children and four grandchildren.

District 11B includes half of Kanabec County and most of Pine County. The convention heard speeches from Rep. Bob Barrett (R-Lindstrom), Rep. Kurt Daudt (R-Cambridge) and Rep. Kurt Bills (R-Rosemount). Rep. Bills recently announced his candidacy for the U. S. Senate.  Bills spoke of the need to address the debt problem of the United States. He teaches Economics at Rosemount High School.

Posted in Campaign Updates, News |